Roll of Pastors

Rev. Thomas Pierson (1829)
Dr. Thomas Dunn
Rev. Wesley Wallace
Rev. James Abbott
Rev. T. Cheeseman (1833)
Rev. James Connely (1834)
Rev. B. Hughes 
Rev. Edward Schock (1841-42)
Rev. Henry D. Moore (1843-44)
Rev. Bartine Twyford (1845-48)
Rev. William Smith (1849)
Rev. J. Timmerman (1850-53)
Rev. William Vanleer (1853)
Rev. T. Taylor Heiss (1854-55)
Rev. Thomas Witsel (1856-58)
Rev. William Vanleer (1859-60)
Rev. Elias Stultz (1861-64)
Rev J. P. Wilson (1865-67)
Rev. T. Appleget (1868)
Rev. J. A. Apgar (1869)
Rev. O. Ellerson (1870-71)
Rev. Firth Stringer (1872-74)
Rev. Henry Watson (1874-75)
Rev. Albert Pierce (1875)
Rev. S. Applegate (1876-77)
Rev. T. B. Castle (1878-79)
Rev. Charles Wilber (1879)

Rev. William Stultz (1880)
Rev. Louis Stultz (1881-87)
Rev. J. H. Algor (1888-1901)
Rev. F. F. Craig (1901-09)
Rev. Louis Stultz (1910-13)
Rev. L. B. Carter (1914)
Rev. J. C. Cody (1915-17)
Rev. Thomas Smith (1917-20)
Rev. J. S. Huizer (1921-22)
Rev. S. T. Dorlin (1922-24)
Rev. E. Edmonds (1925-26)
Rev. William Pettet (1927-28)
Rev.  Thomas Hooper (1929-31)
Rev.  James McCoy (1931-41)
Rev. William Robbins (1941-45)
Rev. Howard W. Kiefer (1945-49)
Rev. A. W. Hurd (1949-54)
Rev. Frank Fidler (1954-64)
Rev. Raymond Rowand (1964-78)
Rev. William Davis (1979-81)
Rev. William Roberts (1982-85)
Rev. Dean Hertzler (1987-88)
Rev. Roy Ingman (1989-90)
Rev. Louis Friend III (1992-96)
Rev. Harold Haines (1997-98)
Rev. Gregory G. Capel, Jr. (1997-present)